Attacking

When a character has spent an action and an attack to strike out at a foe, they are said to be Attacking.

To-Hit

At the heart of attacking is the character's ability to hit their foe. To determine this, the character must know one thing immediately - their character's THAC0. This stands for To-Hit Armour Class 0, or the number that Character would need to hit someone with AC 0. A character with THAC0 20 needs to roll 20 to hit AC 0, a character with THAC0 10 needs to only roll 10! A lower THAC0 is better as it means the character needs to roll a lower number on the dice itself to successfully hit.

To-Hit Roll

The To-Hit Roll is defined by a straightforward formula - it seems awkward at first due to the fact that AC counts down from 10 by default, but people get used to it.

To determine what AC the character can hit with their attack, roll the following:

thac0 - 1d20 - To-Hit Bonuses + To-Hit Penalties.

Effective thac0

To simplify this matter, a player can quickly adjust their Effective THAC0 and then roll something based on that. This is simplified significantly by using Dice Macro.

For example, a character has a thac0 of 14 and is wielding a +1 Longbow against an enemy who is behind 50% cover (-4 to hit). This means that the To-Hit Roll looks something like this:

14 - 1d20 - 1 + 4

Which simplifies down to:

17 - 1d20.

In short, they have an effective THAC0 of 17.

Making The Roll

When the dice is rolled, if the To-Hit roll comes up with the AC of the target or lower the attack is a hit! To continue the above example, the character with the effective THAC0 of 17 rolls 11, this gives them a To-Hit Roll of 6!

If the target has AC 6 or worse, that'd be a hit! If the target has AC 5 or lower, however, that would miss! Say the target has AC 5 - in their current position they'd need to roll 12 or better to hit the target. On a d20, 12 or more is only a 45% chance. If they move to a place where they are behind the target, they lose the -4 penalty and gain a +2 for a back attack. Their effective THAC0 of 17 becomes 11! Now to hit the target, all they need is 6 or more! Their chance to hit when up from 45% to 75%!

Fumbles and Criticals

A roll of 1 is considered a Fumble. This means that, no matter what, the attack has failed.

A roll of 20 is considered a Critical. This means, almost always, the attack is a hit and may be a Critical Hit.

To determine if a Critical hits, compare the effective AC hit to the target's AC and roll damage. If you could lower the effective AC hit by 10 or less and still hit, the attack automatically hits. For every 5 points you would need to decrease the To-Hit Roll's value by, after the first 10, half the effective damage done. The first time this is done will deal 1/2 damage, then 1/4 damage, then 1/8 damage and so on. If reduced to between 1 and half a point of damage, 1 point of damage is still dealt. If this would reduce it below half a point of damage, then no damage is dealt and the attack probably misses.

For example, a character has an effective THAC0 of 18 and rolls 20 on the dice. 18 - 20 gives them a To-Hit roll of -2. Their target is a shadow dragon with AC -12. This is exactly 10 lower than their attack and so it hits normally! If, however, it was darker and the effective THAC0 were 20, this means they would hit AC 0. With the target's AC being 12 points below this, the attack will only do half damage.

This range of values where the character may get a successful hit on a Critical is to prevent situations where a character may somehow achieve a hit from the other side of the planet on a 1 in 20 chance.

Note, Critical Range effects only when Critical Hits can occur, not the automatic hit qualities of a Critical roll.

Critical Hits

When a Critical is rolled, or if an attack roll falls within the Critical Range of an attack, it may be a Critical Hit.

If the attack qualifies for the above and would successfully hit by 5 or more, the attack is a Critical Hit and the character may roll for Severity. In the interest of speed of play, a player may opt to instead roll damage twice or do maximum normal weapon damage without rolling for Severity.

For example, a character has an effective THAC0 of 16 and rolls 20. This gives them a To-Hit Roll of -4. As their target has an AC of 2, they successfully hit by 6. This constitutes a Critical Hit.

The Hit-By-5 rule is to prevent situations where a target with a high AC may only be missed 95% of the time or hit and a Critical Hit is scored automatically.

Modifiers

There are many situations and conditions that can modify the ability of an attack to hit.

Enhancement

Enhancement refers to a bonus or penalty tied to the weapon itself, effectively unchangable. This is usually magical but it could be technological or otherwise. An Enhancement modifier applies to both To-Hit and Damage. The Enhancement modifier of ammunition and ranged weapons stack; thus a +1 Longbow firing +2 Arrows has a +3 To-Hit bonus.

When determining the ability to penetrate Special Defence, the highest Enhancement Modifier across ranged weapon and ammunition is used in Heroic and Epic games. In Traditional Games, only the Enhancement modifier of the ammunition is considered.

If Magical Ammunition is retrieved after successfully hitting a target, its Enhancement bonus decreases by 1, until it becomes 0. Some Ammunition lose all Enhancement bonus immediately on a successful hit. Enhancement penalties are not lost or gained in this manner.

Circumstantial Modifiers

The table below lists a large number of standard To-Hit modifiers that may come up in play, based on the circumstances characters find themselves in. Modifiers that come from attributes, specializations, conditions and so forth are generally not listed here.

Some modifiers stack - a prone target attacking with a crossbow who is able to fire at a target below them has a +5 To-Hit bonus. Other modifiers replace each other - an attacker who is climbing does not gain a +1 bonus To-Hit from being above their opponent, nor does an attacker in Visibility 25% suffer both the penalty for Visibility 25% and Visibility 50% at the same time. A DM decides if multiple modifiers stack or not.

Circumstantial Modifiers
Relative Position	Modifier
Attacker is Above Target	+1
Attacker is Climbing and is Above Target	+0
Attacker is At Same Level as Target	+0
Attacker is Climbing and is At Same Level as Target	-2
Attacker is Below Target	-1
Attacker is Climbing and is Below Target	-4
Prone Stance	Modifier
Attacker is Prone and Attacking with Melee/Throwing Weapon (Size < Attacker Size)	+0
Attacker is Prone and Attacking with Melee/Throwing Weapon (Size = Attacker Size)	-2
Attacker is Prone and Attacking with Melee/Throwing Weapon (Size > Attacker Size)	-4
Attacker is Prone and Attacking with Ranged Weapon (Gun-like - Gun, Crossbow, Blowgun)	+4
Attacker is Prone and Attacking with Ranged Weapon (Other - Bow, Sling)	-4
Target is Prone (Melee Attack)	+4
Target is Prone (Ranged Attack within 10 or less feet)	+0
Target is Prone (Ranged Attack > 10 feet away)	-2
Kneeling Stance	Modifier
Attacker is Kneeling/Sitting and Attacking with Melee or Throwing Weapon	+0
Attacker is Kneeling/Sitting and Attacking with Ranged Weapon (Gun-like - Gun, Crossbow, Blowgun)	+2
Attacker is Kneeling/Sitting and Attacking with Ranged (Other)	+0
Target is Kneeling/Sitting (Melee Attack)	+2
Target is Kneeling/Sitting (Ranged Attack within 10 or less feet)	+0
Target is Kneeling/Sitting (Ranged Attack > 10 feet away)	-1
Balance	Modifier
Attacker is Off-Balance	-2
Target is Off-Balance	+2
Attacker is Off-Balance on Narrow Platform (Tightrope Walking)	-5
Target is Off-Balance on Narrow Platform (Tightrope Walking)	+5
Underwater	Modifier
Attacker is Underwater and does not have a Swim Speed	-2
Target is Underwater and does not have a Swim Speed	+2
Attacker is Underwater (Piercing Melee Weapon or Net)	+0
Attacker is Underwater (Other Weapon)	-4
Attacker is Wading, Target Underwater (Piercing Melee Weapon or Net)	-2
Attacker is Wading, Target Underwater (Other Weapon)	-6
Visibility	Modifier
Target has 25% Concealment	-1
Target has 50% Concealment	-2
Target has 75% Concealment	-3
Target has 90%+ Concealment	-4
Target has 25% Cover	-2
Target has 50% Cover	-4
Target has 75% Cover	-7
Target has 90%+ Cover	-10
100% Visibility (Sunlight)	+0
75% Visibility (Moonlight)	-1
50% Visibility (Starlight)	-2
25% Visibility (Clouded Night)	-3
0% Visibility (Total Darkness)	-4
Per 10 feet between Attacker and Target at 0% Visibility	-1
Range	Modifier
Short Range	+0
Medium Range	-2
Long Range	-5
Extreme Range	-10
Weather	Modifier
pending	pending
Condition	Modifier
Attacker is using Off-Hand	-2
Target is Invisible	-4
Target is Stunned	+4
Flanking (per Outnumbered)	+1
Back Attack	+2, Flatfooted
Sneak Attack	+2, Flatfooted
Target is Unaware, Surprised or Ambushed	+1, Flatfooted
Target is Helpless (Melee Attack)	+10, Flat Footed
Target is Helpless (Ranged Attack)	+5, Flat Footed

Special Circumstances

A few specific circumstances need to be defined when making attack rolls.

Main-Hand vs Off-Hand

Unless a character is Ambidextrous, they possess a Main Hand and an Off-Hand.

An Off-Hand suffers a -2 penalty on To-Hit rolls.

Any Skill Check where the character is forced to use solely their Off-Hand when they would normally use on their Main-Hand suffers a -4 penalty. This does not apply, for instance, to a checks involved in disarming an opponent, but it would apply if a character was attempting to write legibly.

If a character possesses more than two hands, assume half of them are Main-Hands, rounding down, and the rest are considered are Off-Hands. If the character possesses only one hand from their race, unless stated otherwise, this is their Main-Hand. If the character possesses a prehensile tail, feet or other unique appendages not as suited for grabbing as a hand, these are not factored into determining how many Main-Hands vs. Off-Hands the character has - these are all Off-Hands.

If a species has nothing that constitutes a hand but may still have some form of a grip, such as a snake or a slime, this is considered an off-hand for purposes of using weapons but not for purposes of other skills or attacks.

Automatic Hits

Some attacks or actions have an Automatic Hit effect, meaning that no matter what AC they would hit, they hit their target. In these instances, an Attack Roll is only made to determine if it is a Critical Hit or a Fumble.

If an Automatic Hit would be a Fumble, make a new attack roll. If this would hit AC 0, it is not a Fumble.

(firing into melee notes) If characters become clustered together during a fight, it becomes hard to draw a bead on their target. If a character attacks an enemy who has other characters within 5 feet of them, roll a dice to determine which is hit. For instance, if a goblin archer fires at a knight and there are two orc bandits attacking him, the goblin rolls 1d3 – on a 3, he hits the intended target but on a 1 or a 2 he hits one of the orcs! Size also plays a part in this – larger characters take more of the ‘space’ in the roll. For example, if the knight was instead battling two ogres, the archer would roll a d10 – on a 1-4, he hits one ogre, on 5-8 he hits the other and on an 8-9 he hits the knight, as the ogres are one size category larger than him. If a character has the Precision proficiency, they always know who they are aiming at.